RankScoreGenreGame
13.9.18MultiplayerStarcraft
15.9.12MultiplayerLeague of Legends
19.9.04MultiplayerStars!
20.9.03MultiplayerDota 2
42.8.82MultiplayerCounter-Strike
43.8.82MultiplayerWorld of Warcraft
47.8.81MultiplayerUnreal Tournament
64.8.68MultiplayerCounter-Strike: Global Offensive
67.8.61MultiplayerEVE Online
74.8.60MultiplayerRise of Mythos
79.8.56MultiplayerUrban Terror
85.8.52MultiplayerTyrant
90.8.50MultiplayerYu-Gi-Oh! BAM
100.8.45MultiplayerElements
101.8.45MultiplayerGarry's Mod
110.8.42MultiplayerContract Wars
123.8.37MultiplayerCounter-Strike: Source
139.8.31MultiplayerClash of the Dragons
140.8.31MultiplayerHD Xyth
149.8.28MultiplayerCS Portable
157.8.26MultiplayerThe Necronomicon
160.8.24MultiplayerRed Crucible 2
177.8.17MultiplayerWar Thunder
196.8.14MultiplayerSpiral Knights
204.8.12MultiplayerKongai
219.8.08MultiplayerRealm of the Mad God
229.8.06MultiplayerThe Last Stand: Dead Zone
234.8.04MultiplayerCrazy Fairies
274.7.93MultiplayerSAS: Zombie Assault 3
278.7.92MultiplayerPlatform Racing 2
285.7.90MultiplayerTDP4 Team Battle
286.7.89MultiplayerTransformice
299.7.86MultiplayerRIFT
321.7.80MultiplayerShellShock Live
327.7.79MultiplayerStronghold Kingdoms
336.7.78MultiplayerBrick-Force
360.7.74MultiplayerDrakensang Online
368.7.72MultiplayerShellShock Live 2
391.7.70MultiplayerWartune
392.7.70MultiplayerBad Eggs Online
417.7.64MultiplayerMiscrits
424.7.62MultiplayerEverybody Edits
454.7.59MultiplayerMinions
476.7.56MultiplayerPost it Draw it
477.7.56MultiplayerUMAG
480.7.56MultiplayerBeGone: Guerra
495.7.55MultiplayerDream World
506.7.53MultiplayerThe Lord of the Rings Online
560.7.49MultiplayerDueling Blades
575.7.48MultiplayerDungeon Rampage
605.7.45MultiplayerDino Storm
615.7.45MultiplayerCombat Extreme
652.7.42MultiplayerDragons of Atlantis
677.7.40MultiplayerWorld Rebellion II
682.7.39MultiplayerBoxhead Bounty Hunter
697.7.38MultiplayerBackyard Monsters (removed)
751.7.33MultiplayerGame of Thrones Ascent
779.7.30MultiplayerCo-op Toon Shooter: Rise of the fleet
790.7.29MultiplayerStar Trek Online
825.7.26MultiplayerSacred Seasons MMORPG
830.7.26MultiplayerDungeon Blitz
842.7.25MultiplayerDoom Forge
850.7.25MultiplayerWarlock's Arena
859.7.24MultiplayeratWar
886.7.23MultiplayerZilch
889.7.23MultiplayerVerdun
902.7.22MultiplayerStick Arena: Ballistick
913.7.21MultiplayerKingdoms CCG
919.7.21MultiplayerNinja Warz
923.7.21MultiplayerAstroflux
924.7.21MultiplayerDraw My Thing!
974.7.18MultiplayerRemnants of Skystone
975.7.18MultiplayerPirate Galaxy
984.7.17MultiplayerCity of Steam: Arkadia
993.7.16MultiplayerEverQuest® II Free-To-Play. Your Way.™
1012.7.15MultiplayerHeroes of Gaia
1013.7.15MultiplayerCastle Wars 2
1029.7.13MultiplayerLOLcaptions
1031.7.13MultiplayerGuild Wars Factions®
1036.7.13MultiplayerBad Eggs Online 2
1058.7.12MultiplayerLiero
1082.7.10Multiplayerco-op toon shooter
1093.7.09MultiplayerElemental Power
1117.7.08MultiplayerGuild Wars Nightfall®
1118.7.08MultiplayerOf Guards And Thieves
1120.7.08MultiplayerCard Monsters
1139.7.07MultiplayerBattle Conquest
1163.7.05MultiplayerSacred Seasons 2 MMORPG
1168.7.05MultiplayerCritter Forge
1180.7.04MultiplayerFarragomate
1196.7.03MultiplayerColony
1213.7.02MultiplayerChatChat
1221.7.02MultiplayerDawn of the Dragons
1224.7.02MultiplayerScorched Earth
1225.7.02MultiplayerWar of Omens
1227.7.02MultiplayerZombies! Apocalypse - MMO Zombies Massacre
1247.7.01MultiplayerBuggle Connect
1277.6.99MultiplayerThe Secret World
1281.6.99MultiplayerGib Fest Multiplayer
1296.6.98MultiplayerPower Paintball
 
Follow us on Twitter: @5000best
5000 Best Games by Arek Paterek (Twitter), 2014.
Score is based on my judgement, Steam, GOG, and Kongregate.