RankScoreGenreGame
14.9.15ActionDuke Nukem 3D
16.9.10ActionTIE Fighter
17.9.06ActionBlood
30.8.96ActionFreespace 2
33.8.91ActionDescent + Descent 2
44.8.82ActionPsychonauts
50.8.80ActionStar Control 1+2
57.8.77ActionQUAKE
59.8.74ActionDOOM II
61.8.71ActionDoom Roguelike
70.8.61ActionTomb Raider
72.8.60ActionTeam Fortress 2
77.8.58ActionWolfenstein 3D
80.8.56ActionThief™ Gold
81.8.56ActionEffing Worms 2
82.8.55ActionHexen
83.8.55ActionCall of Duty
92.8.50ActionSaboteur
108.8.43ActionCarmageddon Max Pack
114.8.41ActionWing Commander™ 1+2
119.8.39ActionCannon Fodder
120.8.39ActionWing Commander™ 3 Heart of the Tiger™
122.8.37ActionPainkiller Black Edition
124.8.36ActionQUAKE III: Team Arena
127.8.35ActionLeft 4 Dead 2
128.8.35ActionBeyond Good and Evil™
129.8.35ActionFreefall Tournament
131.8.35ActionTyrian 2000
132.8.35ActionDayZ
133.8.35ActionThief™ 2: The Metal Age
135.8.33ActionPrince of Persia
141.8.31ActionWar Inc. Battlezone
144.8.30ActionArma 3
147.8.29ActionGiants: Citizen Kabuto
148.8.28ActionTerraria
150.8.28ActionWarframe
151.8.28ActionPath of Exile
152.8.27ActionOutcast
154.8.27ActionShogo: Mobile Armor Division
155.8.27ActionLearn to Fly 2
156.8.26ActionSouth Park™: The Stick of Truth™
162.8.24ActionFreespace + Expansion
163.8.23ActionStarbound
165.8.22ActionLegacy of Kain: Soul Reaver
167.8.22ActionDark Souls™: Prepare To Die™ Edition
170.8.21ActionMortal Kombat
173.8.19ActionPlanetSide 2
180.8.17ActionMedal of Honor: Allied Assault War Chest
181.8.16ActionBioShock Infinite
185.8.16ActionPortal 2
187.8.15ActionFar Cry 3
190.8.15ActionGrand Theft Auto IV
191.8.15ActionThe Mighty Quest For Epic Loot
193.8.14ActionThe Binding of Isaac
194.8.14ActionHalf-Life
195.8.14ActionSuper Mario Bros.
198.8.14ActionNeverwinter
199.8.13ActionMDK
200.8.13ActionUnreal Tournament 2004 ECE
202.8.12ActionEarthworm Jim 1 + 2
205.8.12ActionQUAKE II
206.8.12ActionRaptor: Call of the Shadows 2010 Edition
212.8.10ActionThief
215.8.09ActionHAWKEN
217.8.08ActionFar Cry®
231.8.05ActionLoadout
232.8.04ActionLearn to Fly
235.8.04ActionDescent 3 + Expansion
239.8.03ActionPrince of Persia®: The Sands of Time
240.8.02ActionBurrito Bison Revenge
242.8.02ActionHalf-Life 2
247.8.00ActionRush Team Free FPS Multiplayers
248.8.00ActionTorchlight II
249.8.00ActionOddworld: Abe's Oddysee
251.7.99ActionUPGRADE COMPLETE!
253.7.99ActionKilling Floor
257.7.98ActionMDK 2
259.7.97ActionJust Cause 2
261.7.96ActionSyndicate Plus™
262.7.96ActionMount & Blade: Warband
264.7.96ActionElephant Quest
268.7.95ActionCrusader: No Remorse™
269.7.95ActionAlone in the Dark 1+2+3
270.7.95ActionThe Last Stand: Union City
271.7.94ActionWing Commander ®: Privateer ™
272.7.94ActionUnreal Gold
276.7.92ActionCall of Duty®: Modern Warfare® 3
277.7.92ActionStrike Force Heroes
279.7.92ActionWing Commander™ 4: The Price of Freedom
294.7.88ActionBatman: Arkham City - Game of the Year Edition
295.7.87ActionBattlefield: Bad Company™ 2
297.7.87ActionIL-2 Sturmovik™: 1946
301.7.86ActionStrike Force Heroes 2
302.7.85ActionToss the Turtle
305.7.85ActionHotline Miami
306.7.85ActionBatman™: Arkham Origins
314.7.82ActionSpace Engineers
315.7.82ActionMax Payne 3
320.7.80ActionFlight
322.7.80ActionThe Last Stand 2
 
Follow us on Twitter: @5000best
5000 Best Games by Arek Paterek (Twitter), 2014.
Score is based on my judgement, Steam, GOG, and Kongregate.